Posted on

It’s Easier to Blame Marketing Than to Admit You Don’t Understand Modern Music

There’s a very common argument that today’s popular songs are only successful because of marketing. Record labels spend millions promoting mediocre music, and people eventually start liking these songs simply because they’ve heard them hundreds of times.

Interestingly, this argument often comes from highly educated musicians who have a very specific idea of what a good song should sound like.

Many of them were trained to evaluate music using concepts and expectations rooted in classical music, jazz, or older pop music. And when a modern song doesn’t follow those conventions, they conclude that it’s simply bad music.

They hear a simple, repetitive, almost static melody and assume there’s nothing musically interesting happening.

But millions of people love that song.

Instead of questioning whether their understanding of melody might be incomplete or outdated, they conclude that people must have been manipulated by marketing.

Because it’s easier to blame marketing than to admit that you don’t understand why something works.

Simpler Doesn’t Mean Worse

One of the most common criticisms of modern music is that today’s songs and melodies are less complex.

And that’s actually true.

But why do we automatically assume that simpler melodies represent musical decline, rather than a change in the language of effective songwriting?

Musical complexity and musical effectiveness are two completely different things.

A musician trained in classical music or jazz might look for melodic movement, interesting intervals, and harmonic complexity. But these are not universal measures of how emotionally effective a melody is.

Interestingly, something similar happened when Miles Davis and other musicians pioneered cool jazz in the late 1940s. Some musicians from the more complex, technically demanding bebop tradition criticized this new, more restrained approach.

But Miles Davis wasn’t simply playing less because he couldn’t play more. He was exploring how to express more with fewer notes.

The focus shifted from technical complexity to emotional precision.

And that’s exactly what we’re seeing in modern pop music.

If Marketing Explains Everything, Why Doesn’t Every Promoted Song Become a Hit?

Record labels invest enormous amounts of money promoting songs every year, yet only a fraction become major hits.

You just don’t hear about most of the unsuccessful ones, precisely because they never became successful.

Of course marketing influences popularity. Nobody disputes that.

But marketing doesn’t explain why people connect emotionally with one song more than another.

Marketing is not an explanation of a melody’s emotional mechanics.

Maybe the Audience Isn’t the Problem

There’s also something rather arrogant about claiming that millions of people only enjoy a song because the media has manipulated them.

You’re essentially saying that your personal musical judgment is more reliable than the actual experiences of millions of listeners who genuinely enjoy that music.

But perhaps there’s a much simpler explanation:

Maybe the listeners aren’t incapable of recognizing good music. Maybe the critic is incapable of recognizing what listeners enjoy about that music.

Spending decades studying music theory doesn’t automatically mean you understand how pop music works in 2026.

Traditional music theory provides plenty of valuable knowledge, but not every songwriting convention taught decades ago is equally relevant today.

In fact, extensive technical training can sometimes become an obstacle when musicians mistake their learned expectations for universal standards of musical quality.

The problem isn’t that these musicians know too much music theory. It’s that they assume what they know applies equally to every genre and every era of music.

Music evolves. Listener preferences evolve. And the language of effective songwriting evolves with them.

Just because a song doesn’t work according to the rules you learned doesn’t mean it doesn’t work.

It might mean you’re using the wrong perspective to understand it.